Auto insurance for households with more cars than drivers.

One policy covers the daily car, the weekend car, and the one parked while your kid is at school. Cars that sit cost less, and the total-loss terms are on this page.

From $118 a month for an example household of two drivers and two cars.

Example household 4 cars, 2 drivers, 2 parked

A drawing of a family home with its garage cut open. Four bays hold a daily wagon on its charger, a silver weekend coupe, a parked hatchback with a sun shade, and a collector car under a fitted cover. A driveway, a tree, low hedges, a basketball hoop, and a lit upstairs window are outside.1234
Example household 4 cars, 2 drivers, 2 parked

Every car in your garage, on one policy.

Most insurers price each car as if it commutes. We price each one by how it is used.

  1. Bay 1

    The daily car

    It commutes and sits in parking lots all day, so it carries the most risk: $36 a month in the example.

    Liability
    Injuries and damage you cause to others, up to your limits.
    Collision
    Repairs to your car after a crash, less your deductible.
    Comprehensive
    Theft, fire, hail, flood, or a deer.

    On every level. Limits vary by state.

  2. Bay 2

    The weekend car

    Out on Saturdays and the odd road trip, so fewer miles: $22 a month in the example.

    Rented and borrowed cars
    A rental or a friend's car, for up to 90 days, abroad too under local insurance rules.
    Trip help
    A covered crash 50+ miles from home: a hotel, meals, and the trip home. Capped at $5,000 in some states.

    Household and Collector levels. Varies by state.

  3. Bay 3

    The parked car

    The hatchback waits at home while your kid is at college.

    Parked-car rate
    $19 a month in the example, on every level.
    Student-away discount
    Takes off more while the driver is at school without the car. Household and Collector.

    Varies by state and vehicle.

  4. Bay 4

    The collector car

    Out maybe ten Sundays a year, and worth more to you than to a price guide.

    Agreed value
    A value set with you when you buy. A total loss pays it or the cash value, whichever is higher.
    Your choice of shop
    Specialist repairs at the shop you pick.

    Collector level, from $214 a month for 2 drivers and 4 cars in the example. Varies by state.

Four cars, one policy, one renewal date. Cars registered in another state need a separate policy.

Cars that sit cost less.

A car that sits most of the month costs less to insure than one that commutes. That is the parked-car rate, on every level.

Example estimate, not a quote

Sample household: 2 drivers with a daily and a weekend car on Essential, plus parked cars.

Daily car
$36
Weekend car
$22
Parked car
$19
Each driver
$30
Parked cars
0

$118a month, example

Real premiums depend on the drivers, the cars, and the state.

Price every car in the builder

What we pay if a car is totaled.

If the car is totaled, you don't pay a deductible. We pay the agreed value or the cash value, whichever is higher.

Worked examples. The figures are examples.

A weekend coupe with an agreed value

Cash value on the day
$38,500
Agreed value on the policy
$42,000
Deductible on a total loss
$0
We pay
$42,000

A financed sedan, worth less than the loan

Left on the loan
$24,000
Cash value, paid to the lender
$19,000
Gap payoff covers
$5,000

Agreed or cash value

We pay the higher of your agreed value or the car's actual cash value.

Agreed value comes with the Collector level. Varies by state.

Agreed or cash value

Doesn't cover: An agreed value that wasn't set before the loss. Those cars get actual cash value.

No deductible on a total loss

When a covered car is a total loss, no deductible comes off the payout.

Varies by state and vehicle.

No deductible on a total loss

Doesn't cover: Repairs short of a total loss. Your usual deductible applies.

Loan and lease gap payoff

Owe more on the loan or lease than the car is worth? We pay the difference after a total loss.

Household and Collector levels. Varies by state.

Loan and lease gap payoff

Doesn't cover: Overdue payments, lease mileage penalties, unrefunded deposits, add-on warranties, and balances rolled over from an earlier car.

Repairs, rentals, and the drive home.

After a covered crash, the car goes to the shop you pick and gets original parts. Household and Collector add a rental while it is fixed.

Inside an open garage, a car owner pulls a dark fitted cover back from a silver classic coupe.
Garage, late afternoon

OEM parts

Covered repairs use original manufacturer parts.

OEM parts

Doesn't cover: Glass. It's replaced with OEM-equivalent glass.

Rental up to 90 days

A rental for as long as the repair takes, up to 90 days, delivered to you.

Household and Collector levels. Varies by state.

Rental up to 90 days

Doesn't cover: Delivery without comprehensive and collision on at least one car, in states that require it.

Towing to your shop

After a covered accident, we tow the car to the shop you choose.

Towing to your shop

Doesn't cover: Breakdowns with no accident. Those fall under roadside assistance.

Roadside assistance

Lockouts, breakdowns, and flat tires.

Household and Collector levels. Varies by state.

Roadside assistance

Doesn't cover: Anything but private passenger cars.

Three levels, priced for real households.

Each price is an example for the sample household named under it, paid monthly.

Essential

from $118a month

Example: 2 drivers, a daily and a weekend car

  • Liability, collision, and comprehensive
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist
  • OEM parts on repairs
  • Towing to the shop you choose
  • No deductible on a total loss
  • Parked-car rate
Quote Essential

Household

from $162a month

Example: 2 drivers, 3 cars, one parked

  • Everything in Essential
  • Student-away discount
  • Rented and borrowed cars, up to 90 days
  • Delivered rental during repairs
  • Loan and lease gap payoff
  • Trip help 50+ miles from home
  • Roadside assistance
Quote Household

Collector

from $214a month

Example: 2 drivers, 4 cars, one a collector car

  • Everything in Household
  • Agreed value on any car on the policy
  • Shop choice for specialist repairs
Quote Collector

Real premiums depend on the drivers, the cars, and the state. Every line of each level is on Plans.

Stories from multi-car households.

Illustrative stories, not customer reviews.

Our son left for college and his hatchback stayed home. It moved to the parked-car rate with the student-away discount, and it was still insured at Thanksgiving.

Dana Two drivers, four cars

A pickup ran a light and totaled my sedan. I owed more on the loan than it was worth. Gap payoff covered the difference, with no deductible.

Marcus Two drivers, three cars

My 1967 coupe goes out maybe ten Sundays a year. We agreed on its value when I bought the policy, before anything happened.

Ruth Two drivers, four cars, one collector

Questions people ask before they switch.

Policy documents govern. This page summarizes coverage; it is not the policy.

Do I pay to insure a car that just sits in the garage?

Yes, but less. A car that sits most of the month gets the parked-car rate, $19 a month in our example, and it stays on the policy.

What happens if my car is totaled and I still owe on the loan?

We pay the higher of the agreed value or the cash value, with no deductible. On Household and Collector, gap payoff covers what's left on the loan or lease. It doesn't cover overdue payments, lease mileage penalties, unrefunded deposits, add-on warranties, or balances rolled over from an earlier car.

Will repairs use original parts or aftermarket ones?

Original manufacturer (OEM) parts on covered repairs. Glass is the exception: it is replaced with OEM-equivalent glass.

How long will you pay for a rental while my car is in the shop?

For as long as the repair takes, up to 90 days, on Household and Collector. The rental can be delivered, though many states require comprehensive and collision on at least one car for that.

My kid is away at college without the car. Can I pay less?

Yes. The student-away discount applies on Household and Collector, and the car left at home can move to the parked-car rate.

How do I add a teen driver?

Add them from your account or write to support@moreshield.com. The teen driver program includes driver education and a guide for the parent and teen talk.

Get a quote in three steps.

It asks for no phone number, license, VIN, or password, and it sends nothing.

  1. Step 1 The household

    How many drivers and cars, and your ZIP code.

  2. Step 2 The cars

    Each car's year and use: daily, weekend, parked, or collector. Then a level, with its example price.

  3. Step 3 Review

    Check the details and agree to the Terms.

A convertible under a dark fitted cover on a brick driveway in daylight, a few fallen leaves on the cover, the garage door closed behind it.
Driveway, a covered convertible

Get a quote for the whole garage.

Get a quote